greenltd wrote:Top gear has not been a car show for a long time, its a show that just happens to have cars in it.
This, so much this. Anyone watching Top Gear thinking they're going to take in factual statements and objective thoughts on the car being presented is watching it for entirely the wrong reasons. Reviewing cars is like reviewing wine. You either care, or you don't, and if you do care, and have first-hand experience, you probably won't agree with the reviewer on the nuances anyway. Cars and wine are alike there, in that it's all about the nuances.
What it is, and what it excels at, is taking cars we cant have, putting people in them that will drive them like we wouldn't dare, then tell us which of the cars we cant have they'd prefer to drive in a way we wouldn't.
They have "the stig" for getting down to the nuts-and-bolts - how fast a car is around their circuit, everything else comes down to whether you like your wines to have woody undertones or fruity tangs.
Having said that, Top Gear with the current cast as a YouTube channel would be excellent. I suspect if the producers told Clarkson there were no rules to break, he'd be a lot less of a knob-jockey.