BadBong wrote:(given that the car is setup for 15” originally).
Forget the change from 15" to 16". You can change the wheels and still have the same rolling diameter (or a very similar one) if you choose the right tyre width and offset.
http://www.miata.net/garage/tirecalc.html
Play with the calculator a bit and you'll be able to understand it better.
It sounds to me like you want a good looking rim that won't adversely affect the handling and will have a good range of tyres available. Without wanting to sound like Mr Morlock... The factory rims fit that description. Why not keep them? Paint them if you are looking for a bit of a change.
Whatever you decide; good luck, I hope it works out.